A short Series On The Dynamics of Innovation Units, Labs and Hubs.
Understanding the patterns and key decision points that turn innovation into theatre.
Innovation Theater is the easy villain
Whenever an innovation lab, hub, or unit underdelivers, the finger is quickly pointed at innovation theater. Too much show, not enough substance. But in over 15 years of working with innovation managers and senior executives, I have never met anyone who set out to create Innovation Theater.
What actually happens is more subtle. Innovation slips into theater through a series of unnoticed dynamics. They start with the best intentions: making innovation work, creating value for customers, and driving the business forward. Yet many units end up performing for visibility rather than delivering for impact.
Over the years, I’ve observed five recurring patterns that quietly shape the trajectory of innovation units. Each begins with a decision that feels logical in the moment. But once you’re inside, the dynamic reinforces itself, making it hard to escape and even harder to see alternatives.
Innovation Theater is not the cause of failure, it’s a symptom. The cause lies in the choices, structures, and assumptions that quietly set the stage long before the curtain rises.
In this series, I’ll walk you through the five most common ones:
Pattern 1: The Engagement Cycle
Pattern 2: The Cost Center Trap
Pattern 3: The Startup Hype
Pattern 4: The Illusion of Control
Pattern 5: The Fancy Lab Effect
What it is
In my experience, the Engagement Cycle is the most common of the five patterns.
I have encountered it in many innovation units and worked with teams trying to reverse it. And I think there is a simple reason why it appears so often.
Many innovation units start from the same position. A small team is created with just a few people and limited budget, while expectations are remarkably high. The new unit is expected to transformthe organization, and sometimes even help turn the company into an innovation leader.
But a small team cannot create that kind of impact on its own.
So the obvious response is to mobilize the organization. Invite people to participate. Ask for ideas. Build communities. Run workshops and challenges. Create visibility and engagement.
Often, there is hardly another option.
That is why the Engagement Cycle begins with the best intentions: to make innovation participatory, inclusive, and visible. Yet over time, energy can shift from creating external value to maintaining internal visibility. The theater grows, the impact shrinks, and engagement eventually declines.
How it starts
Innovation units are often launched understaffed, underfunded, and over promised. With limited resources and no decision rights, they face an early choice: to either become a driver of innovation, or an enabler for the rest of the organization.
Many choose the enabler path. It feels safer, more inclusive, and achievable with a small team. And once you’re an enabler, the easiest activity is engagement. However, you’re engaging innovation amateurs. And what is a safe way to engage with amateurs? Ask them for their ideas, because everyone has ideas.
And that’s where the cycle begins.
The two entry paths that converge
There are two typical ways innovation units enter the Engagement Cycle, and both lead to the same place.
Path B begins with high engagement.
Participation surges. Hundreds of ideas flow in from across the organization, and a small team spends weeks, sometimes months, sorting, clustering, and ranking submissions.
Most ideas are unqualified, few have sponsors or budgets, and feedback to contributors is slow or nonexistent. Disillusionment spreads, enthusiasm fades, and eventually engagement drops. The team concludes that it now has an engagement problem.
Path A begins with low engagement.
Participation in campaigns and events is modest. The team diagnoses a communication problem and concludes that employees simply don’t understand what the innovation unit does.
In response, they pivot toward internal marketing, building slide decks, holding town halls, and running awareness campaigns to increase participation.
Engagement metrics start to improve, but business outcomes do not. The team gains visibility, but not credibility.
Both paths converge on the same loop.
Both paths converge on the same loop. Engagement becomes the goal in itself, and the unit begins optimizing for internal visibility instead of external market value.
Paradoxically, chasing engagement often leads to disengagement.
Innovation Pattern 01. The Engagement Cycle.
High engagement innovation programs have become so commonplace that few question their logic. But step outside the bubble and the contrast is obvious. Can you imagine any other professional function relying so heavily on amateur input? Would a marketing department crowdsource its campaign strategy from employees across unrelated divisions?
Of course not. Those disciplines rely on skilled professionals with clear mandates, resources, and accountability. Yet in innovation, we do exactly that. We invite everyone to contribute, regardless of expertise, and convince ourselves that idea volume equals progress.
It doesn’t. What looks democratic on the surface is structurally misleading.
The system behind the illusion
At the heart of the Engagement Cycle lies the belief that participation itself creates progress. Everyone is invited to contribute, but few have the mandate or means to act. Decision rights, budgets, and accountability remain elsewhere, while the system rewards visibility over market value.
The safest activity is to run events and collect ideas, because this creates visible effort without much risk. The hardest activity is to make a call, place a bet, and ship something. Democracy without decision power produces noise, not direction.
The result is a system that constantly expands its surface area while shrinking its business impact. Innovation teams don’t set out to create theater; they drift into it because the structure leaves them no other option.
Early warning signs
When innovation loses focus, two new informal roles quietly emerge.
The second is the innovation accountant.
The team becomes busy measuring, sorting, and reporting.
They cluster ideas, categorize submissions, and maintain dashboards of participation metrics.
They spend more time managing ideas than creating outcomes, and soon the team’s core competence becomes administration: keeping the system running, not creating value through it.
The first is the innovation marketer.
Its purpose is to make innovation liked and understood across the organization.
Campaigns, newsletters, and roadshows follow, each designed to raise awareness and invite participation.
The message shifts from “Here’s what we’ve built” to “Here’s why innovation matters.”
Both archetypes are symptoms of the same pattern. The focus of innovation turns inward, away from the market.
The end state, if uncorrected
Left uncorrected, the Engagement Cycle ends in quiet exhaustion. The innovation team slowly drifts into a role that sustains itself rather than the business.
Over time, trust erodes. Employees stop submitting ideas because they no longer believe anything will happen with them. Sponsors disengage because innovation fails to deliver business outcomes. The intent was engagement, but the result is the opposite: disengagement.
The conclusion is always: innovation doesn’t work here.
How to break the Engagement Cycle
You cannot fix a structural problem with more enthusiasm, more communication, or another round of idea campaigns. Breaking the Engagement Cycle requires rebuilding the sequence: foundation first, engagement later.
1. Revisit the early decision
If you must start small, act like a driver, not a cheerleader. Claim a focused space where you hold decision rights and a small execution budget. Building credibility through impact takes longer, but it’s solid. Participation does not build credibility; impact does.
2. Build the foundation before engagement
Define two or three exploratory questions that anchor all activity, and agree in advance who decides and what budget will be invested in exploring each question. A team that knows its scope, funding, and decision logic does not need mass participation to stay relevant.
3. Replace idea volume with decision quality
If an idea doesn’t link to an exploratory question or a significant problem, and a sponsor willing to invest in it, don’t pursue it. Fewer, more qualified inputs lead to better decisions and clearer accountability.
4. Earn credibility through problem solving
If you’re starting out with a small team and budget, focus first on solving tangible problems and deliver visible results for one or two important sponsors. Once you’ve proven reliability in problem solving, you can take on innovation work with higher risk and higher potential reward that explores new opportunities.
5. Set engagement boundaries
Engage with purpose, not with volume. Use your exploratory questions as the anchor for engagement, and bring in experts where their knowledge truly matters. Define clear expectations and timelines for their contribution.
6. Measure what matters
Replace participation metrics with evidence of value. Look at customer behavior changes and willingness to pay, cycle time from decision to shipped outcome, and cost avoided, risk reduced, or revenue created.
A quick diagnostic
The Engagement Cycle hides behind good intentions and positive energy. To see whether your innovation unit is caught in it, look at where time, attention, and credibility are really spent.
Ask yourself whether you spend more time explaining innovation than doing innovation, whether progress is communicated through stories of activity or evidence of impact, and how much capacity goes into sorting, clustering, and marketing ideas rather than solving concrete problems.
Also consider what would happen if engagement suddenly dropped. Would your impact shrink, or would your focus improve? And do your metrics describe activity inside the organization or value created outside it?
The first step out is not more participation, but more precision, fewer ideas, better questions, and decisions that lead to tangible results.
The bottom line
Confront your engagement model. Innovation that depends on visibility will always chase attention; innovation that depends on impact can stand on its own. You don’t need more participation. You need clear questions, real decisions, and visible results.
Engagement follows credibility, not the other way around.
This pattern is part of a series of five distinct patterns that explore common dynamics in corporate innovation:
Pattern 1: The Engagement Cycle
Pattern 2: The Cost Center Trap
Pattern 3: The Startup Hype
Pattern 4: The Illusion of Control
Pattern 5: The Fancy Lab Effect
Each pattern shows how good intentions in innovation can turn into structural traps, and how to avoid them.
If you’d like to discuss how to course correct or redesign your Innovation Unit, Hub, or Lab before shutting it down, I’m happy to help.
You can reach me directly at: